New York Cuisine - A Ranking of NYC's Top Places To Eat!

With an upcoming first-time trip to the Big Apple, I thought it would be fun to research an "ultimate culinary adventure" within NYC! My mouth was watering most of the time while looking into this stuff.

This guide is the top 25 ranked spots, blending iconic eateries with hidden gems across Manhattan, Brooklyn, and beyond. 

The rankings of restaurants can vary based on several factors, including:

Critic Reviews: Many lists are compiled based on professional reviews from food critics and publications. These reviews assess the quality of food, service, ambiance, and overall experience.

Customer Ratings: Websites like Yelp, TripAdvisor, and Google Reviews gather ratings and feedback from diners, which can heavily influence rankings.

Awards and Recognitions: Restaurants that have received Michelin stars, James Beard Awards, or other culinary accolades often rank higher due to their prestige.

Social Media Buzz: Popularity on platforms like Instagram, TikTok, and food blogs can also play a role, as trending spots often attract more attention.

Longevity and Reputation: Established restaurants with a long history and a loyal customer base may be favored in rankings due to their sustained quality and service.

Now, without further ado...

1. Le Bernardin

Cuisine: French/Seafood
Vibe: Elegant and elevated dining
Known for its stunning seafood dishes, Le Bernardin is a true Michelin-starred treasure. Highlights include the delicate, citrus-kissed tuna and the breathtakingly fresh oysters, perfect for celebrating big moments.

2. Katz’s Delicatessen

Cuisine: Jewish Deli
Vibe: No-frills, classic New York
Katz’s is famous for its towering pastrami sandwiches, served with a side of history and humor. This Lower East Side staple is perfect for anyone craving an authentic taste of NYC’s past.

3. Momofuku Ko

Cuisine: Modern American/Asian Fusion
Vibe: Trendy and experimental
Chef David Chang’s brainchild, Momofuku Ko offers an innovative, seasonal tasting menu that’s always surprising. The signature dishes, like the savory foie gras, are as delicious as they are unexpected.

4. Peter Luger Steak House

Cuisine: Steakhouse
Vibe: Old-school steak joint
A Brooklyn landmark since 1887, Peter Luger is where steak dreams come true. Order the porterhouse for two, and savor each bite of the smoky, perfectly charred meat.

5. Dirt Candy

Cuisine: Vegetarian
Vibe: Modern and vibrant
With dishes like hot carrot sliders, Dirt Candy proves that vegetables can be just as indulgent as meat. This Lower East Side spot is the place for veggie lovers and curious eaters alike.

6. Russ & Daughters Café

Cuisine: Jewish Deli
Vibe: Cozy with vintage charm
Famous for its bagels and lox, this spot on the Lower East Side has been a brunch essential since 1914. Start with the smoked fish platter, paired with pickled onions and capers.

7. Eleven Madison Park

Cuisine: Modern American
Vibe: Luxurious fine dining
This Michelin three-starred beauty offers a multi-course experience with flavors from around the world. The roasted duck with lavender honey is the stuff of culinary legend.

8. Roberta’s

Cuisine: Pizza
Vibe: Laid-back and artsy
This Bushwick pizza haven is known for its wood-fired pies, like the “Bee Sting,” topped with honey and chili flakes for a sweet-spicy punch.

9. Prince Street Pizza

Cuisine: Pizza
Vibe: Classic NYC pizza joint
Famous for its pepperoni square slices with a perfect crisp and rich sauce, Prince Street Pizza is the go-to place for a classic, messy NYC slice.

10. Per Se

Cuisine: French/American
Vibe: Refined and elegant
At Per Se, indulge in the signature Oysters and Pearls, a caviar and oyster dish that feels like pure luxury. The Central Park views are a bonus.

11. Ivan Ramen

Cuisine: Ramen/Japanese
Vibe: Hip and casual
Ivan Orkin’s ramen joint in the Lower East Side serves up a unique twist on Japanese noodle soup, with toppings like pork belly and marinated eggs.

12. Joe’s Pizza

Cuisine: Pizza
Vibe: No-frills and classic
Joe’s Pizza in Greenwich Village is the epitome of NYC slice culture. Grab a foldable, cheesy slice with a crispy crust and you’ll feel like a local.

13. Carbone

Cuisine: Italian-American
Vibe: Glamorous old-school Italian
Known for its spicy rigatoni vodka and table-side Caesar salad, Carbone is a nostalgic journey through Italian-American cuisine.

14. The Modern

Cuisine: Modern American
Vibe: Artistic and sophisticated
Attached to MoMA, The Modern’s menu is as artful as the museum’s exhibits. Try the wagyu beef tartare and enjoy the perfect museum day.

15. Lucali

Cuisine: Pizza
Vibe: Rustic and cozy
Lucali in Brooklyn is BYOB and all about the pies. Their classic margherita with fresh basil and garlic is a pizza purist’s dream.

16. Shake Shack (Original in Madison Square Park)

Cuisine: Burger joint
Vibe: Casual and lively
The iconic ShackBurger is all about juicy beef, melted cheese, and a fluffy potato bun. It’s a New York City classic for locals and tourists alike.

17. Minetta Tavern

Cuisine: French-inspired American
Vibe: Old-school charm
Go for the Black Label Burger, a rich, dry-aged blend that’s juicy perfection. It’s what burger dreams are made of!

18. Cosme

Cuisine: Modern Mexican
Vibe: Chic and trendy
Cosme’s duck carnitas are legendary, served with fresh tortillas for a DIY taco experience. This spot puts a modern twist on Mexican classics.

19. The Halal Guys

Cuisine: Middle Eastern street food
Vibe: No-frills food cart
Famous for gyros and platters packed with flavor, The Halal Guys’ carts are a must-visit for their iconic white and red sauces.

20. Daniel

Cuisine: French
Vibe: Formal fine dining
A classic in the fine-dining scene, Daniel’s tasting menus are filled with luxurious ingredients like black truffle and caviar.

21. Tao Downtown

Cuisine: Pan-Asian
Vibe: Lavish and energetic
Tao is an experience. With dishes like crispy Peking duck, the food is as exciting as the ambiance, making it a fun dinner destination.

22. J.G. Melon

Cuisine: Burger joint
Vibe: Laid-back and timeless
J.G. Melon serves one of the best cheeseburgers in NYC, complete with crinkle-cut fries and a side of charm.

23. Sushi Nakazawa

Cuisine: Sushi
Vibe: Intimate and refined
Sushi Nakazawa offers a luxurious omakase experience. Each bite is melt-in-your-mouth delicious, perfect for sushi aficionados.

24. Dominique Ansel Bakery

Cuisine: Bakery/Pastries
Vibe: Quaint and trendy
Home of the cronut, Dominique Ansel Bakery always delivers when it comes to inventive, Instagram-worthy pastries.

25. Xi’an Famous Foods

Cuisine: Chinese/Shaanxi street food
Vibe: No-frills and fast-paced
Known for their hand-pulled noodles and spicy lamb burgers, this spot offers unique, crave-worthy flavors that pack a punch.

Each of these 25 iconic eateries brings a unique flavor to NYC’s food scene. Whether you’re craving pizza, fine dining, or street food, these top picks will help you taste the best the city has to offer. I'm sure there are places missing from this list that are just as good - please let us know in the comments your favourites and where else we should go!

_________________________________________________________________

Sup. We appreciate you reading our travel blog. To receive exclusive member-only updates, subscribe to our free newsletter, The Nomad's Compass. You'll receive Belly's latest news, drops, and exclusive codes in your inbox. You can unsubscribe at any time to stop receiving updates. See you in the next one!